Which is Better? Propane, Natural Gas or Electric Furnace or Heat Pump

Is propane, natural gas, or an electric furnace or heat pump better

Propane, electric furnace, natural gas, and heat pump are essential appliances in the home, making it difficult to know which is better. Each gas and appliance is essential, but they all have a way they contribute to the energy bill. Some contribute little while others consume lots of energy, yet it is a tough decision. This guide on propane, heat pump, electric furnace, and natural gas is to clarify their importance and which is better.

CostWhich is Better? Propane, Natural Gas or Electric Furnace or Heat Pump

  • Heat Pump

Installing a heat pump will cost you between $3,500 to $4,500. But there are differences in sizes, system efficiency, and the type that alter the prices. For example, air-to-air heat pumps are cheaper because they work with the air around them. In addition, they are simple but need help to handle cold climates. On the other hand, geothermal works by getting underground to tap from the constant 50-degree temperature the earth produces.

  • Furnace

For a furnace, the installation man will charge at least $4,500 for a gas furnace and $4,000 for an electric furnace.

  • Propane

Propane is efficient and cheap. For example, a cubic foot of propane is 2,500 BTUs.

  • Natural gas

Natural gas has limitations if you want to install it at home. Also, it takes a homeowner $6.23 to get 1,000 cubic feet of natural gas.


  • Heat Pump

Heat pumps can last for 15 years, depending on maintenance and usage. And other components, like refrigerant pumps, may damage before time.

  • Furnace

The furnace’s lifespan is over 20 years. However, it will need regular maintenance to last longer.

  • Natural gas

A natural gas furnace is expected to last between 15 and 20 years. The equipment may last longer under proper care. It is time to look for a second option once your gas furnace is 15 years old.

  • Propane

The container for storing propane (propane shelf)can last 30 years, while the propane itself can last forever. In addition, a gas cylinder’s lifespan fluctuates according to counters but generally lasts for 10 to 15 years.


Which Is Best for You?

Choosing between these appliances is on a case-by-case basis. The heat pump is better for people living in a warmer climate because it will be more efficient and DIY friendliness. However, people in colder climates will work better with an electric furnace, especially when there is natural gas. The appliance has a streamlined appearance with efficient working power.

On the other hand, propane gives you sufficient BTU for each dollar. The fuel efficiently runs a home’s cooking and high-heat grilling. Propane can work when other systems are unavailable or when you are relocating. However, natural gas is adequately available and constantly flowing to your home. The gas payment is paid as you go making it cheaper since you pay for what you use.

In conclusion, the better one will be the one that fits your lifestyle and current situation. You have to assess the pros and cons of each gas and appliance, access to the fuel, infrastructure, and what you plan to use it for.

If you need service on your heat pump, contact us at Pilchuck Heating.

Get a Quote Today

More Advice for Homeowners